The Pagan Society began as a student organization in 2009 at the University of Utah calling itself the Salt Lake Pagan Society and because of university requirements, University of Utah Pagan Society. Then called the Salt Lake City Pagan Society, the organization moved off campus and changed its name to the current form beginning in December 2018 and officially in 2019. The student group was aimed at practitioners of all Neopagan faiths and continued to embrace this philosophy after becoming an official organization off campus. The group began publishing a Contemporary Pagan literary journal Enheduanna in 2016. Some issues appear under both names of the entity, the reissues bearing second editions under their new name. The group's president, Daniel Cureton, is also the chief editor of the journal. The current society practices the New American Tradition offering a degree system and ordination. According the the blog as of this writing, the Society is syncretic including "concepts of Wicca, Druidry, Shamanism, Norse, High Magic, and cultural traditions to create a mix and balanced approach to Nature spirituality."